Leadership Shake-Ups and Second Chances: AFL’s Bold Moves for 2026 — A Season of Surprises and Second Chances
The AFL landscape is shifting dramatically as two clubs unveil bold captaincy decisions, while a former player gets an unexpected lifeline. But here’s where it gets controversial: are these moves setting the stage for triumph or turmoil? Let’s dive in.
Brisbane’s Triple Threat: A New Era of Leadership
After Lachie Neale’s emotional decision to step down as co-captain—a move fueled by personal challenges—Brisbane Lions have taken a daring step by naming not one, not two, but three skippers for the 2026 season. Josh Dunkley and Hugh McCluggage join Harris Andrews at the helm, forming a leadership trio that’s as intriguing as it is ambitious. And this is the part most people miss: this isn’t just about filling a void—it’s about redefining what leadership looks like in the AFL. But will three heads truly be better than one?
Dunkley’s promotion comes after three stellar seasons since his move from the Western Bulldogs, while McCluggage’s career-best 2025 campaign earned him his first All-Australian honor. Together, they’ll lead an expanded eight-man leadership group that includes rising stars like Cam Rayner and Will Ashcroft. The Lions are gunning for a historic three-peat premiership, but with great ambition comes great scrutiny. Can this collective leadership model thrive under pressure?
St Kilda’s Co-Captaincy Gamble
Meanwhile, St Kilda has doubled down on shared leadership, naming Jack Sinclair and Cal Wilkie as co-captains. This move follows Jack Steele’s departure to Melbourne, leaving big shoes to fill. Sinclair, a reliable half-back with 210 games under his belt, and Wilkie, a bargain-buy recruit entering his eighth season, are no strangers to responsibility—both served as vice-captains last year. But here’s the question: Can two leaders with contrasting styles unite a team hungry for success?
Will White’s Unexpected Lifeline
In a twist that’s equal parts heartwarming and head-scratching, former Carlton small forward Will White has been offered a second chance by the Western Bulldogs. After being overlooked by the Blues, White will train under the SSP rules following James Harmes’ retirement. It’s a classic underdog story, but will he seize this opportunity to reignite his career?
Eddie McGuire’s Medal Controversy
And now, the controversy no one saw coming: Eddie McGuire is fuming over Nick Daicos’ snub for the EJ Whitten Medal. Despite Daicos’ jaw-dropping 38 disposals and 13 score involvements, Lachie Ash took home the honors. McGuire’s response? He’s jokingly vowed to bring his own medal to the next State of Origin match. But is this just a lighthearted jab, or does it expose deeper flaws in how we recognize AFL talent? Let’s debate this in the comments.
What’s Next?
As the 2026 season kicks off, these leadership shake-ups and second chances will be under the microscope. Will Brisbane’s three-skipper model revolutionize AFL leadership, or will it create chaos? Can St Kilda’s co-captains unite a team in transition? And will Will White prove his doubters wrong? One thing’s for sure: this season promises drama, debate, and unforgettable moments. What’s your take? Share your thoughts below—let’s spark some friendly (or not-so-friendly) AFL banter!
